When a company fails to respect the working hours set for its employees, it can face significant administrative penalties ranging from 60 to 6,250 euros for each affected worker. This article looks in detail at the obligations regarding working time, how breaks must be managed and what penalties can be imposed on the employer in case of non-compliance.
Breaching working time rules can result in administrative fines of up to 6,250 euros, especially when the provisions on the average length of the working day are violated. In cases of unused holiday, in addition to the financial penalty, the advance payment of social security contributions may be required under current regulations.
Types of penalties
Breaching time tracking rules can constitute serious infringements, with fines ranging from 626 euros at the minimum level to 6,250 euros at the maximum level. In addition, there are further penalties linked to specific requirements of the time record, even when the company complies with the general rules. Infringements are classified into three categories:
- Minor infringements: Fines between 60 and 625 euros. They occur when the company does not adequately inform workers about their working conditions or does not provide time record reports.
- Serious infringements: Fines between 625 and 6,250 euros. They apply when employees work unpaid overtime or when there are irregularities in the time record.
- Very serious infringements: Fines between 6,250 and 187,515 euros. They are imposed when minors under 18 work overtime, when wages go unpaid or when payments are repeatedly delayed.
Applicable regulations
The reference regulation is the BOE (Spain's Official State Gazette) Real Decreto-ley 8/2019 (Royal Decree-Law 8/2019) of 12 March, which requires companies to keep a record of their employees' working hours. Failing to comply is considered a serious infringement under article 34 of the Estatuto de los Trabajadores (Workers' Statute), with penalties ranging from 751 to 7,500 euros.
The aim of this regulation is to prevent abuses regarding working hours, ensuring that employees complete their working day and that overtime is properly compensated, either through financial payment or equivalent rest time.
How many consecutive hours can you work in the same day?
Collective agreements set the maximum weekly working time, which cannot exceed 48 hours per week on average over a seven-day period, including overtime. This calculation is made over a maximum period of four months, extendable to six or twelve months for technical or organisational reasons.
Article 7 of the Ley de Infracciones y Sanciones en el Orden Social (Law on Infringements and Penalties in the Social Order) states:
“The breach of the legal or agreed rules and limits on working hours, night work, overtime, complementary hours, rest periods, holidays, leave, working time records and, in general, the working time referred to in articles 12, 23 and 34 to 38 of the Workers' Statute”.
Read also: Intensive working day
Remote work and the right to disconnect
People who work remotely have the right to digital disconnection outside their working hours, under article 88 of Ley Orgánica 3/2018 (Organic Law 3/2018). Ley 10/2021, de trabajo a distancia (Law 10/2021 on remote work), reinforces this right:
««People who work remotely, particularly teleworking, have the right to digital disconnection outside their working hours […] The employer's duty to guarantee disconnection entails a limitation on the use of company technological means of communication and work during rest periods […]».»
Article 18. Right to digital disconnection.
In all cases, companies must keep an up-to-date record of working hours. Non-compliance can lead not only to financial penalties but also to labour disputes and possible civil claims.
Legal risks
In addition to administrative penalties, breaching working hours rules can lead to legal action by employees, such as:
- Claims for breach of contract.
- Claims for damages.
- Actions for violation of labour rights, including unpaid overtime.
- Claims for discrimination or retaliation.
- Actions for unjust enrichment.
The document you sent me states:
“Failure by the employer to comply with working time rules can result in penalties, such as administrative fines ranging from 249 to 1,800 euros […] In addition, civil matters could be brought that could directly affect the employment relationship with individual staff members.”
Can penalties affect workers?
Employees also have an obligation to record their working hours honestly. Article 58 of the Workers' Statute establishes:
- Workers may be sanctioned by company management for breaches of their labour obligations.
- The assessment of misconduct and penalties will be subject to review by the competent court.
- Penalties consisting of a reduction of holidays or rest rights may not be imposed.
Recommendations
Since breaching working hours rules can lead to penalties and civil disputes, it is advisable to use an automated time management system. Solutions range from manual methods to mobile apps and clock-in terminals. One of them is Light of Work, a free time tracking tool that lets you record clock-ins and clock-outs, manage breaks and download reports in PDF format in line with current regulations.
⌚ LIGHT OF WORK is a cross-platform Human Resources app that manages the complete time tracking system of your company, business or self-employed activity, and the projects the hours are spent on. It also manages other HR areas such as employee absences and holidays. 🤙🏼 DownloadsConclusions
Companies are required to record the start and end times of each working day and keep these records for four years. They must include daily and weekly rest periods and adapt to arrangements such as remote work. Non-compliance can lead to financial penalties and civil disputes that directly affect the employment relationship.